The Baysinger Files
Archive/Case No. 09/Confirmed real
CASE No. 09 · BUREAU OF UNEXPLAINED PHENOMENA

The Nimitz 'Tic-Tac'

Off San Diego, California · November 2004

Navy fighter pilots chase a white, wingless oval with no exhaust and no explanation.

Confirmed real
EXHIBIT 09 — case illustration
Status
Confirmed real
Location
Off San Diego, California
Era
November 2004
File
BX-09
The short version

In November 2004, fighter pilots from the carrier USS Nimitz reported and recorded an encounter with a smooth, white, oval object that moved unlike any known aircraft. Unlike most UFO stories, this one is officially confirmed: the Pentagon released the footage and the Navy verified it as authentic, unexplained aerial phenomena.

Case timeline
Nov 2004
Nimitz strike group radar tracks anomalous objects; F/A-18s are vectored to intercept.
Nov 14, 2004
Cmdr. David Fravor reports a 'Tic-Tac'-shaped object; the 'FLIR1' video is recorded.
2017
The footage is published and reported by major media.
2020
The Department of Defense officially releases and authenticates the videos.
The claim
What people believe

The claim is straightforward: trained naval aviators encountered a craft displaying flight characteristics — sudden acceleration, no visible propulsion — beyond known technology.

Evidence locker
EX 09-01
Radar tracks

Multiple sensors logged objects descending rapidly from high altitude.

EX 09-02
Pilot testimony

Cmdr. Fravor described a ~40-foot white oval that reacted to his approach and shot away.

EX 09-03
FLIR video

Cockpit infrared footage shows the object, later officially released.

The record
What the evidence shows

The encounter and footage are officially confirmed: the Pentagon released the videos and the Navy verified them as real, unidentified. What the object actually was remains unresolved — the official position is genuine uncertainty, not a claim of alien origin.

The skeptic’s file
The case against

Skeptics offer candidate explanations — sensor artifacts, parallax, distant aircraft, or balloons — and note that infrared footage is easy to misread. None has been confirmed as the answer.

What won’t close
Open questions

This is the rare case where the establishment says, on the record, that it doesn't know. That official 'unidentified' is exactly why the Tic-Tac reframed the whole UFO conversation around the term UAP.

Recent developments

Where the file stands now

The Nimitz case helped trigger formal U.S. government attention to UAP. The Pentagon's AARO has since reviewed thousands of reports; its 2024 findings resolved most as ordinary objects while leaving a small set unexplained, and a March 2024 historical review found no evidence of recovered alien technology. In 2025–2026 the Department of Defense continued publishing additional UAP case files and imagery.

Source summary: U.S. DoD / AARO reports, 2024; ongoing DoD UAP releases.

In the culture

The Nimitz encounter, broken by major newspapers in 2017, moved UFOs from tabloid territory into congressional hearings and mainstream defense reporting.

Further reading
  • U.S. Navy / DoD statements authenticating the Navy videos (2020)
  • Cmdr. David Fravor public interviews
  • Office of the Director of National Intelligence UAP assessments (2021 onward)
Cross-referenced files